Introduction: Not This, Not This
The Upanishads are known for their paradoxical and indirect ways of pointing to the ultimate truth. Among all their methods, one stands out as the most famous and most powerful: Neti Neti. This Sanskrit phrase, which appears in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, means “not this, not this” or “not so, not so.” It is a method of negation — a systematic process of denying that the ultimate reality (Brahman) is any object that can be perceived, conceived, or described.
Neti Neti is not a statement about what Brahman is. It is a statement about what Brahman is not. It is a finger pointing at the moon, not the moon itself. It is a neti (negation) of everything that is not the Self, leaving only the Self as the unnegatable remainder.
This article explains what Neti Neti is, how it is used in the Upanishads, and how to apply it as a practical method of self-inquiry.
The Origin: Brihadaranyaka Upanishad
The phrase Neti Neti appears in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (2.3.6), one of the oldest and largest of the principal Upanishads. The context is a dialogue about the nature of Brahman. The sage Yajnavalkya is asked to describe Brahman. He replies:
“Now, therefore, the description of Brahman: ‘Not this, not this’ (Neti Neti). There is no other description beyond this.”
Yajnavalkya then explains: Brahman is not the body, not the senses, not the mind, not the intellect, not the ego, not any object of experience. All of these can be negated. What remains after the negation of all objects is Brahman — not as an object, but as the subject, the witness, the Self.
This is the essence of Neti Neti. Brahman cannot be described positively because any positive description would turn Brahman into an object. The only accurate description is negation: “not this, not this.”
Why Neti Neti? Why Not a Positive Description?
You might ask: Why can’t the Upanishads just tell us what Brahman is? Why all this negation? The answer is fundamental to Vedanta.
Brahman is not an object. You can describe a table because it is an object. You can describe a feeling because it is an object of experience. But Brahman is the subject — the one who knows all objects. You cannot make the subject into an object. You cannot describe the describer. You cannot know the knower as a known.
Any positive description limits Brahman. If you say “Brahman is light,” you have limited Brahman to light and excluded darkness. If you say “Brahman is consciousness,” you might mistakenly think Brahman is a property of something else. The Upanishads do use positive descriptions (Sat-Chit-Ananda, for example), but these are pointers, not literal descriptions. They are meant to be understood as “not not this” after the negation of all limited qualities.
Negation is the only accurate method. Neti Neti does not leave us with nothing. It leaves us with the unnegatable — the one who is doing the negating. You can negate your body. You can negate your thoughts. You can negate your emotions. You can negate your ego. But you cannot negate the one who is negating. That one is the Self.
How Neti Neti Works: The Process of Negation
Neti Neti is not a philosophical theory. It is a practical method of self-inquiry. Here is how it works, step by step.
Step 1: Identify something you are currently identifying with. For example, “I am this body.”
Step 2: Apply Neti Neti: “Not this, not this. I am not this body.”
Step 3: Investigate directly. Look at your body. Is it permanent? Is it unchanging? Is it the source of awareness? The answer is no. The body is an object of awareness, not awareness itself.
Step 4: Rest in the awareness that remains after the negation. Do not look for a new object. Simply be the awareness that is already there.
Step 5: Repeat with the next identification: “I am this mind.” Apply Neti Neti: “Not this, not this. I am not this mind.” Investigate. The mind is an object of awareness. Thoughts come and go. You are the witness of thoughts, not the thoughts themselves.
Step 6: Continue through all objects: emotions, sensations, the ego, the intellect, the sense of “I” as a separate person. Negate each one.
Step 7: What remains? Not the body, not the mind, not the emotions, not the ego, not any object. What remains is pure, objectless awareness — the witness of all negations. That is the Self (Atman). That is Brahman.
What Can Be Negated? The Full Scope of Neti Neti
Neti Neti can be applied to every object of experience. Here is a comprehensive list:
| Category | Examples | Negation |
|---|---|---|
| Physical body | Hands, feet, organs, cells | Not this |
| Senses | Seeing, hearing, touching, tasting, smelling | Not this |
| Vital energies | Breath, life-force (prana) | Not this |
| Mind (Manas) | Thoughts, doubts, desires, imaginations | Not this |
| Intellect (Buddhi) | Decisions, knowledge, discrimination | Not this |
| Ego (Ahamkara) | The sense of “I” as a separate person | Not this |
| Memory (Chitta) | Impressions, memories, habits | Not this |
| Emotions | Anger, fear, joy, sadness | Not this |
| Deep sleep | The bliss of deep sleep (Anandamaya Kosha) | Not this |
| All objects | Everything that can be perceived, conceived, or described | Not this |
After negating all of these, what remains? Not a thing. Not an object. Not a concept. Pure, self-luminous, non-dual awareness. That is the Self.
Neti Neti and the Five Sheaths (Pancha Kosha)
The Taittiriya Upanishad provides a systematic framework for Neti Neti through the five sheaths (koshas). Each sheath is negated, leading to the Self beyond.
| Sheath | Negation |
|---|---|
| Annamaya Kosha (Food Sheath) | Not this. I am not the physical body. |
| Pranamaya Kosha (Vital Air Sheath) | Not this. I am not the breath or life-force. |
| Manomaya Kosha (Mind Sheath) | Not this. I am not the mind or emotions. |
| Vijnanamaya Kosha (Intellect Sheath) | Not this. I am not the intellect or ego. |
| Anandamaya Kosha (Bliss Sheath) | Not this. I am not even the bliss of deep sleep. |
Beyond all five sheaths is the Self (Atman). The Self is not a sheath. It is the witness of all sheaths.
Neti Neti and the Four States of Consciousness
The Mandukya Upanishad applies Neti Neti to the three states of consciousness, revealing the fourth (Turiya) as the Self.
| State | Negation |
|---|---|
| Waking (Jagrat) | Not this. I am not the waking state. |
| Dreaming (Swapna) | Not this. I am not the dreaming state. |
| Deep Sleep (Sushupti) | Not this. I am not the deep sleep state. |
After negating all three states, what remains is Turiya — the witness of waking, dreaming, and deep sleep. Turiya is the Self.
Neti Neti in the Bhagavad Gita
The Bhagavad Gita does not use the phrase Neti Neti, but its teaching is the same. Krishna repeatedly instructs Arjuna to negate identification with the body, senses, mind, and ego.
Chapter 2, Verse 20:
“The Self (Atman) is never born nor does it ever die. It is not slain when the body is slain.”
This is the result of Neti Neti. After negating the body, the Self remains.
Chapter 13, Verse 2:
“Know that I am the knower of all fields of activity within all bodies. And know that the knowledge of both the field and the knower is true knowledge.”
The “knower of all fields” is the Self. It is not the field (the body, mind, etc.). It is the witness.
Chapter 5, Verse 8-9:
“I do nothing at all,” thinks the steady knower of truth, even while seeing, hearing, touching, smelling, eating, walking, sleeping, breathing…
This is the practical application of Neti Neti. The realized one knows that all actions belong to the body, senses, and mind — not to the Self.
What Neti Neti is NOT
To understand Neti Neti correctly, it is important to know what it is not.
Neti Neti is not a statement that the world is an illusion. The world is not being negated as nonexistent. It is being negated as not the Self. The world exists as a relative, dependent appearance. But it is not what you truly are.
Neti Neti is not a rejection of the world. You do not need to renounce the world or hate your body. You only need to stop identifying with them. You can still act, love, and live fully — but without the illusion that you are the body or mind.
Neti Neti is not a philosophical dead end. It does not leave you with nothing. It leaves you with the unnegatable — the Self. The Self is not nothing. It is the fullness of existence, consciousness, and bliss.
Neti Neti is not a mantra to be repeated mechanically. Repeating “not this, not this” without investigation is useless. Neti Neti is a method of direct self-inquiry. You must actually look at your body, your thoughts, your ego, and see that they are not you.
Practical Application: How to Use Neti Neti in Daily Life
You do not need to sit in a cave to practice Neti Neti. You can use it in your daily life.
When you feel identified with your body: Say “Not this, not this. I am not this body. I am the one who knows this body.”
When you feel identified with your thoughts: Say “Not this, not this. I am not this thought. I am the witness of this thought.”
When you feel identified with your emotions: Say “Not this, not this. I am not this anger. I am not this fear. I am the witness of this emotion.”
When you feel identified with your ego: Say “Not this, not this. I am not this ‘I’ that claims ownership. I am the witness of this ego.”
When you feel identified with your successes or failures: Say “Not this, not this. Success and failure are experiences. I am the witness of success and failure.”
When you feel identified with your roles (parent, worker, friend): Say “Not this, not this. I am not this role. I am the witness of this role.”
Do not just repeat the words. Feel the shift. Rest in the awareness that remains.
The Result: What Remains After Neti Neti
After negating everything that can be negated — body, senses, mind, intellect, ego, emotions, memories, the three states, the five sheaths — what remains?
The Upanishads answer:
“That which remains after ‘Neti Neti’ is the Self (Atman). It is unseen but the seer. It is unthinkable but the thinker. It is unknown but the knower. It is the witness of all. It is Brahman.”
The Self is not an object. It cannot be described. But it can be realized. It is what you are when you stop identifying with objects. It is the awareness reading these words. It is the presence that knows you are here. It is you.
Conclusion: The Unnegatable Remainder
Neti Neti is the method of negation — the systematic denial that the ultimate reality (Brahman) is any object that can be perceived, conceived, or described. It is not a philosophical theory. It is a practical method of self-inquiry. You apply it to your body, your mind, your ego, your emotions, your memories, your states of consciousness — everything you have mistaken for your Self. You say “Not this, not this.” You look directly. You see that each object is not you.
After all negations, what remains? Not a thing. Not an object. Not a concept. Pure, self-luminous, non-dual awareness. That is the Self. That is Atman. That is Brahman. That is what you are.
As the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad declares:
“Now, therefore, the description of Brahman: ‘Not this, not this’ (Neti Neti). There is no other description beyond this.”
Negate everything. Rest as the witness. Know the Self. Be free.
Om Shanti Shanti Shanti.